Close
 
Thursday, 19 November 2026   |   Thursday, 8 Jum. Akhir 1448 H
Online Visitors : 0
Today : 27.076
Yesterday : 114.972
Last week : 821.392
Last month : 11.429.130
You are visitor number 105.216.314
Since 01 Muharam 1428
( January 20, 2007 )
AGENDA
  • No data available

 

Artikel

06 agustus 2008 05:59

Can Tourism Provoke Terrorism?

Can Tourism Provoke Terrorism?
Bali bomb memorial

By: Michael Grosspietsch

Introduction

“Why Bali? Are we no longer safe anywhere? Is this the perfidious strat­egy of terror: to carry fear and horror even into the last corners of peace­ful holiday harmony and tropic bliss?“ (Tagesspiegel, 2002)

Questions like these went around the world after the Bali bombings on 12th October 2002, accompanied by renewed calls to finally accept that terrorism remains a serious imminent threat to the global societies. The incident was also a sad reminder that those who want to successfully combat terrorism need to identify and understand its root causes – a task which is extremely difficult and controversial.

At the World Development Summit in Monterey in March 2002, world political leaders identified poverty as being “intrinsically linked to the fight against terrorism” (von Hip­pel, 2002:26). Nevertheless, there is little evidence that poverty, as well as lack of education or injustice are the direct root causes of terrorism (Rubenstein, 2002). Ac-cording to Krueger and Maleckova (2002), terrorists in the Middle East not only en­joyed a living standard above the poverty line, but normally had at least a secondary education. Von Hippel (2002) adds that the hijackers of the 11th September 2001 at-tacks in the USA were neither poor nor uneducated, acknowledging that they even qualified to take flight lessons and acquire the technical skills to accomplish their tasks. The findings of both, von Hippel and Krueger and Maleckova, confirm previous research results (e.g. Pizam & Smith, 2000) which suggest that terrorism is most often rooted in deep social, political and sometimes religious motives. Krueger and Maleck­ova come to the conclusion that terrorism “is more accurately viewed as a response to political conditions and long-standing feelings of indignity and frustration” (2002:I). Though it is noted that a universally accepted definition of terrorism does not exist (Sönmez & Graefe, 1998), the most often cited definitions like the current FBI definition, nevertheless, often include a notion like “in furtherance of political or social objec­tives” (FBI, undated). [1]

What are these political, social or religious objectives? Sönmez and Graefe (1998) found out that many terrorist incidents are primarily focused on tourists or the tourism industry. In this context, newspaper commentaries after the Bali bombings raised the question whether tourists are just the ‘scapegoat‘ and ‘soft‘ targets (Kornelius, 2002) or whether the tourism industry itself is provocative enough to lead to violent re­sponses including, in extreme cases, terrorist acts (FAZ, 2002). In this essay, it will be examined whether there is any evidence that tourism actually constitutes one of the potential reasons that lead to terrorist activities.

As the latest attacks in Djerba and Bali both were carried out by Muslim activists against tourism targets, it will, first of all, be examined whether religions in general – and Islam in particular – are directly opposed to tourism.

Do religions directly oppose tourism in order to justify terrorist attacks against tourism targets?

Recent terrorist activities have been stamped as Islamic war against the West (e.g. Krauel, 2002; Perras, 2002; von Hippel, 2002). At least twice activists struck in major tourist destinations, namely on the Tunisian island Djerba in April 2002 and on the In­donesian island Bali in October 2002. Attacks by specific religious groups are not new, so that it is legitimate to ask what role religion plays in recent terrorist attacks on tour-ism targets.

By examining the case of Islamic activists in Egypt in the early 1990s, Aziz (1995) comes to the conclusion that there is no world religion that is against tourism per se. In the case of Islam he discovers evidence that the notion of travel is accepted both im­plicitly and explicitly. On the one hand, Muslims are encouraged through Koran and Hadith to travel in order to trade, to visit relatives and friends, to seek knowledge, to appreciate the greatness of God‘s creation and, of course, for pilgrimage reasons. As hosts, on the other hand, they have a duty of hospitality towards travellers who have been permitted by the Islamic State authority to enter the territory – regardless of race, colour, nationality or religion.

Therefore, no direct hostility towards or rejection of tourism can be attributed to relig­ion in general – and to Islam in particular. However, it cannot be ruled out by this ar­gumentation that the impacts of tourism and, especially, the behaviour of tourists will cause a religious group to react in a xenophobic way. Hence, the potential impacts of tourism need to be analysed according to their suitability to provoke a reaction as strong as a terrorist act.

Do negative socio-economic and socio-cultural impacts of tourism potentially cause xenophobia that is able to provoke terrorist activities?

Contrary to some perceptions of observers from developed countries, most members of host communities in developing countries generally desire change and improvement of their lifestyles through new job opportunities and increased income generated by tourism (Wall, 1997). Nevertheless, a variety of social problems arise when they start losing control over the changes, resulting in increased tension, hostility and suspicion towards tourism (Reisinger, 1994). Potential negative impacts include socio-economic and socio-cultural problems.

Despite the general increase in tourism benefits, the generated income is often highly unequally distributed (Urry, 1990). Tosun (2002) notes in the case of Turkey that local people simply cannot afford to establish proper hotels and shops, leading to high rates of foreign ownership, a loss of control over local resources and substantial overseas leakage of tourism earnings. This socio-economic alienation is even described by some commentators (see e.g. Brohman, 1996; France, 1997; Holden, 2000) as neo­or post-colonialist domination, “where all the power and control in the global tourism system remains in the ‘North‘, and within which the environments and cultures of the ‘South‘ are exploited” (Holden, 2000:20). Those benefits that accrue to the local com­munity are also unevenly distributed, causing conflict between those who benefit and those who do not (Joseph & Kavoori, 2001). Apart from that, while improved infrastruc­ture is regarded as a major positive impact of tourism development (Kreag, 2001), many of the new tourist facilities, such as golf courses or luxury hotels, are of little benefit to the majority of the local population (Urry, 1990). And in many local areas, a rise in prices of goods and services is noted (Furze et al., 1996).

The new job opportunities also influence the socio-economic sphere of a community. Animosity is created between the local population and expatriates who often hold the managerial level jobs, while locals are only offered the semi-skilled or unskilled jobs (Khan, 1997). Furthermore, even these low-paid job opportunities can disturb local family economies when suddenly children earn more than their parents, or wives more than their husbands (Furze et al., 1996).

Brunt and Courtney (1999) suggest that potential socio-cultural impacts lead to a longer-term, graduate change in the values, beliefs and cultural practices of a society. Although Smith (1989) notes that cultures continually change with or without tourism, she also suggests that tourism is an important agent of culture change and has the ability to accelerate it. Negative impacts are most perceived as a dual process of cul­tural commodification and acculturation (Joseph & Kavoori, 2001).

Social anthropologists like Selwyn (1994) examine the commercialisation of culture and cultural artefacts which appear primarily as saleable commodities. In various des­tinations, cultural and religious practices are found to be reconstituted or adapted to suit the needs of tourists (Brunt & Courtney, 1999). Joseph and Kavoori (2001), for example, come to the conclusion that the rituals and traditions of the religious Indian town Pushkar are changed in function from sacred to explicitly commercial enterprise. Similarly, Besculides et al. (2002) suggest that festivals and dances in Bali that were previously considered sacred are now being performed for tourists. Furthermore, the mass production for tourism demand of culturally important items, often altered by ideas in the form of new symbols and materials, may ‘devalue‘ the original items (Furze et al., 1996) or lead to a clearly distinctive art form different from traditional styles (Besculides et al., 2002).

Some commentators suggest that the commodification of local culture becomes most evident and leads to the most significant protest and opposition by the host communi­ties when tourists behave inappropriately, pretending that they should be able to par­ticipate in cultural rituals or activities at any price (Furze et al., 1996) or should be al-lowed to wear any dress they like to visit cultural and religious sites (Holden, 2000). In this context, Teye et al. (2002) observe that the generally positive perception of tour­ists in Ghana is undermined by individuals who behave and dress in a ‘shocking‘ way including men with pierced ears and women wearing very short dresses. The often quoted words of a native Hawaiian in Pfafflin (1987:577) are significant here: “We don‘t want tourism. We don‘t want you. We don‘t want to be degraded as servants and dancers. This is cultural prostitution. I don‘t want to see a single one of you in Hawaii. There are no innocent tourists.”

Cultural commodification is, in many cases, accompanied by a process of accultura­tion or assimilation (Joseph & Kavoori, 2001). According to Reisinger (1994), attitudes and relations change when members of two different ethnic groups interact socially. Carter and Beeton (undated) note that this process of intensified borrowing from each other might be highly asymmetrical and have increasingly negative effects in the host society.

Tourists inevitably have an important influence on lifestyles across the community, perceivable especially at the individual level. In the case of Zanzibar, Goessling (2002) discovers that the displays of wealth and the attraction of consumerism portrayed by tourists lead to a focus on cash-income. Changing conceptions of time and identity among local people on the Tanzanian island are accompanied by considerations of individual benefit that become central to the locals‘ attitudes and relationships in deal­ing with tourists and also among themselves. Joseph and Kavoori (2001) add that lo­cals in Pushkar / India rapidly adopt Western culture such as dress code, alcoholism, drug use or openness to sexual behaviour. Even worse effects are found in Turkey where the crime rate, the drug addiction, prostitution and gambling are increasing rap-idly (Tosun, 2002).

Apart from individuals, changes in community value systems and community organisa­tion are also found (Smith & Krannich, 1998). For example, traditional family relation-ships lose their importance or even disrupt (Kreag, 2001). And, although the notion of ‘the community‘ is most often no more than a myth because members have different opinions and goals, tourism further contributes to the division between groups with divergent interests, such as young Nepalese who are excited about Western con­sumer goods and old Nepalese who see their authority undermined (Butcher, 1997). Furthermore, local languages or dialects erode or are completely lost as a result of an influx of tourist languages (Besculides et al., 2002).

In conclusion, in the light of all these potential negative socio-economic and socio­cultural impacts, some kind of reaction from the host society is reasonably predictable, whether it is tension, hostility, suspicion or violent attacks. This is especially true where trade-offs between positive and negative impacts are perceived to be too high. In this context, Taylor (1995) suggests that in most societies different communities and different members of a community will respond in different ways to tourism. However, it cannot be excluded that certain individuals or groups who support strong cultural or, especially, religious values and feel that these values are threatened by tourism to an extent that is increasingly unbearable, use terrorist acts as ultimate means to combat the threat.

Analysis whether socio-economic and/or socio-cultural impacts caused recent terrorist attacks in Egypt and Bali

While Ryan (1993) disputes the existence of a direct relationship between terrorist at-tacks against tourists and tourism itself in the cases of Corsica and Wales, Aziz (1995), however, offers a different conclusion in the case of Egypt:

Starting in 1974, massive tourism development in Egypt, supported by public funds, lead to the establishment of luxury ‘ghettos‘, while basic infrastructure requirements of locals living in surrounding villages and other parts of Egypt, such as water, sewage, power, telecommunications and community facilities, remained unmet. The socio-economic problems were further aggravated because very few members of the local population found employment in the luxury development, so that almost no socio-economic benefits accrued to local people.

Furthermore, socio-cultural conflict was created because of the clashing cultures and values of mostly Muslim Egyptians and mainly Western tourists. Certain tourist behav­iours, such as consumption of pork and alcohol, disrespect towards dress, or codes of behaviour incongruent with Islamic tradition, contributed to the local people‘s frustra­tion. And cultural exchange through tourism was almost completely diminished be-cause of language barriers.

The almost complete absence of any benefit and the obvious violations of Islamic cul­tural values and traditions created an atmosphere of rejection of tourism that culmi­nated in terrorist violence against tourism targets in the early 1990s. Aziz further ex-amines whether tourists were the real targets and comes to the conclusion that “they are used as a tool to attack the government and to knock down one of the main pillars of the Egyptian economy” (1995:94). The government was perceived as entirely cor­rupt, accepting the Western domination represented by multinational companies, the media and, especially, tourists. Wahab (1995) concurs that Egypt‘s terrorist attacks against tourists represented their desire to revive classic Islamic societal rules to resist the corruption of modernity. In response to Aziz and Wahab, Sönmez summarises: “Tourism can inspire terrorist violence by fuelling political, religious, socioeconomic, or cultural resentment and be used as a cost effective instrument to deliver a broader message of ideological/political opposition. In either case, the choice of the tourist as target is not coincidental.” (1998:426,427). Therefore, although terrorists primarily wanted to strike the Egyptian government, the socio-economic and socio-cultural im­pacts of tourism played a very important role in the evocation of terrorist acts in Egypt.

In a second case study, similarities or differences between the attacks in Egypt and the Bali bombings of 2002 will be examined. Although different commentators have observed incidents of negative socio-cultural impacts (e.g. Urry, 1990; Besculides et al., 2002), the Hindu majority has never been known for its rejection of tourism (Ke­stenholz, 2002). Furthermore, the tourism industry accounts for 3.5 million jobs on the island, offering extensive socio-economic benefits (Anturi, undated). Hence, it is not astonishing that the suspected Muslim terrorists come from outside of the island (Goethe Institute Inter Nationes Press, 2002).

However, it should not be forgotten that, although renowned for its tolerant and mod­erate form of Islam, Indonesia is the country with the highest Muslim population in the world. And Bali‘s ‘paradise world‘ with its loose sexual morality and high levels of alco­hol consume definitely constitutes an enormous provocation to Islamic culture and tra­ditions. Further anger among fundamental Muslims was caused by the election of the moderate President Megawati Sukarnoputri in 2001, a woman as head of an Islamic state, immediately perceived as being corrupt to Western influences (Abdoolcarim, 2003).

Therefore, the terrorist attacks on Bali can be explained by a combination of religious and political opposition to both the tolerant and moderate government and the domina­tion of Western life-styles as portrayed by tourists. With only partly congruence to the findings of the Egypt case study above, tourists seem to be targeted because they are viewed as ambassadors for their countries and because the tourism industry is one of the main pillars of the national economy. The actual socio-economic and socio-cultural impacts of tourism on the island itself appear to be negligible.

Conclusion

The case studies of Egypt and Bali have presented only little common ground in order to answer the question whether socio-economic and socio-cultural impacts of tourism lead to terrorism. While considerable evidence of such a relationship was found in the case of Egypt, the correlation appeared to be negligible in the case of Bali.

A direct rejection of tourism by religion per se could not be established, however tour-ism development perceived as threatening Islamic culture and traditions and not offer­ing any benefits to local people did, to a large extent, provoke the acts in Egypt. The bombings on Bali, however, have to be interpreted in the context of the wider terrorist war against Western values that culminated with the 11th September 2001 attacks in the USA. In both cases, violence was used ‘in furtherance of political or social objec­tives‘ – but the role that tourism played appeared to be different. The findings suggest that tourism, indeed, has the potential to directly provoke terrorist activities – but a generalisation does not hold true, and the wider political, ideological, social and reli­gious circumstances have to be examined case by case.

References

Abdoolcarim, Z. (2003) Standing up for Islam. Time Magazine, 161 (9), 10/3/2003.

Anturi, J.K. (undated) Indonesia tourism sector post Bali tragedy. www.economicreview.net (10 Mar 2003).

Aziz, H. (1995) Understanding attacks on tourists in Egypt. Tourism Management, 16 (2), 91-95. Besculides, A., Lee, M.E. and McCormick, P.J. (2002) Residents‘ perceptions of the cultural benefits of tourism. Annals of Tourism Research, 29 (2), 303-319.

Brohman, J. (1996) New directions in tourism for Third World development. Annals of Tourism Re-search, 23 (1), 48-70.

Brunt, P. and Courtney, P. (1999) Host perceptions of sociocultural impacts. Annals of Tourism Re-search, 26 (3), 493-515.

Butcher, J. (1997) ‘Sustainable development or development?‘. In: Tourism and sustainability – princi­ples to practice. Ed: M.J. Stabler. CAB International, Oxon, pp.27-38.

Carter, R.W. and Beeton, R.J.S. (undated) Managing cultural change and tourism: a review and per­spective. University of Queensland,
http://www.nrsm.uq.edu.au (10 Mar 2003).

FAZ (2002) Der Tourist als Provokation. Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (15 Oct 2002), Frankfurt. FBI (undated) Terrorism defined. http://www.homelandsecurity.com/ (17 Mar 2003).

France, L. (1997) ‘Introduction‘. In: The Earthscan reader in sustainable tourism. Ed: L. France. Earthscan Publications Ltd., London, pp.1-22.

Furze, B., de Lacy, T. and Birckhead, J. (1996) Culture, conservation and biodiversity. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester.

Goessling, S. (2002) Human-environmental relations with tourism. Annals of Tourism Research, 29 (2), 539-556.

Goethe Institute Inter Nationes Press (2002) Terrorism has reached the Isle of Bali. Oct. 2002. www.goethe.de (10 Mar 2003).

Holden, A. (2000) Environment and tourism. Routledge, London and New York.

Joseph, C.A. and Kavoori, A.P. (2001) Mediated resistance. Tourism and host community. Annals of Tourism Research, 28 (4), 998-1009.

Kestenholz, D. (2002) Terror im Paradies. Die Welt (14 Oct 2002), Berlin.

Khan, M.M. (1997) Tourism development and dependency theory: mass tourism vs. ecotourism. ??, 988-991.

Kornelius, S. (2002) Terror und Taten. Süddeutsche Zeitung (13 Oct 2002), München.

Krauel, T. (2002) Al Qaida holt wieder aus. Die Welt (14 Oct 2002), Berlin.

Kreag, G. (2001) The impacts of tourism. Sea Grant, Minnesota, http://www.seagrant.umn.edu (10 Mar 2003).

Krueger, A.B. and Maleckova, J. (2002) The economics and the education of suicide bombers. Does poverty cause terrorism? The New Republic (24 Jun 2002), pp.1 -11.

Perras, A. (2002) Des Terrors neue Heimat. Süddeutsche Zeitung (15 Oct 2002), München.

Pfafflin, G. (1987) Concern for tourism: European perspectives and response. Annals of Tourism Re-search, 14, 576-579.

Pizam, A. and Smith, G. (2000) Tourism and terrorism: a quantitative analysis of major terrorist acts and their impact on tourism destinations. Tourism Economics, 6 (2), 123-138.

Reisinger, Y. (1994) ‘Social contact between tourists and hosts of different cultural backgrounds‘. In: Tourism: the state of the art. Eds: A.V. Seaton, C.L. Jenkins, R.C. Wood, P.U.C. Dieke, M.M. Bennett, L.R. Maclellan and R. Smith. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, pp.743-754.

Rubenstein, C. (2002) An attack on all free societies. The Review (Nov 2002), Melbourne, editorial. Ryan, C. (1993) Crime, violence, terrorism and tourism: an accidental or intrinsic relationship? Tourism Management, 14 (3), 173-183.

Selwyn, T. (1994) ‘The anthropology of tourism: reflections on the state of the art‘. In: Tourism: the state of the art. Eds: A.V. Seaton, C.L. Jenkins, R.C. Wood, P.U.C. Dieke, M.M. Bennett, L.R. Maclellan and R. Smith. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, pp.729-736.

Smith, M.D. and Krannich, R.S. (1998) Tourism dependence and resident attitudes. Annals of Tourism Research, 25 (4) 783-802.

Smith, V.L. (1989) ‘Eskimo tourism: micro-models and marginal men‘. In: Hosts and guests. The an‑

thropology of tourism. Ed: V.L. Smith. University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, pp55-82. Sönmez, S.F. (1998) Tourism, terrorism, and political instability. Annals of Tourism Research, 25 (2),

416-456.

Sönmez, S.F. and Graefe, A.R. (1998) Influence of terrorism risk on foreign tourism decisions. Annals of Tourism Research, 25 (1), 112-144.

Tagesspiegel (2002) Nirgends mehr sicher. Tagesspiegel (14 Oct 2002), Berlin.

Taylor, G. (1995) The community approach: does it really work? Tourism Management, 16 (7), 487-489. Teye, V., Sirakaya, E. and Sönmez, S.F. (2002) Residents‘ attitudes toward tourism development. An­nals of Tourism Research, 29 (3), 668-688.

Tosun, C. (2002) Host perceptions of impacts. A comparative tourism study. Annals of Tourism Re-search, 29 (1), 231 -253.

Urry, J. (1990) The tourist gaze. Sage Publications Ltd., London.

von Hippel, K. (2002) The roots of terrorism: probing the myths. The Political Quarterly, 25-39.

Wahab, S. (1995) ‘Terrorism: a challenge to tourism‘. In: Security and risks in travel and tourism. Pro‑

ceedings of the Talk at the Top Conference. Mid-Sweden University, Östersund, pp.84-108.

Wall, G. (1997) ‘Rethinking impacts of tourism‘. In: Tourism development: environmental and commu‑

nity issues. Eds: C. Cooper and S. Wanhill. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, pp.1-9.
__________

Michael Grosspietsch is a lecturer at the Institute of Political Science at the University of Münster, Germany. He is also the Managing Director of Sustainable Development through Tourism (www.sd-tourism.org). This paper originates from his research in 2003. Contact: michael@sd-tourism.org.

Source: sd-tourism.org
Credit Photo: www.travelblog.org


  

[1] Current FBI definition on terrorism (FBI, undated): “Terrorism is the unlawful use of force or violence against persons or property to intimidate or coerce a government, the civilian population, or any segment thereof, in furtherance of political or social objectives.”

 
Read : 3.699 time(s).

Write your comment !